At the wine section of my local millennial targeted grocery store( organic but prepared foods) I happened upon a woman studying the label of the Store Branded fish oil versus something scribbled on a scrap of paper.
So I simply asked her if she thought it was a good brand.(I tend to do that sort of thing. )
“I am not sure “, she replied looking into my face. “Can you help me?
“Well…” I stated … I just switched to another fish oil after doing my homework, and I — I got cut off. I was going to say I buy fresh fish almost weekly.
“Really? “ she said- “That is exactly what I am trying to do – so what fish oil did you buy?”
Recently I was looking for a good ratio of Medium chain TriGlycerides to other Omega triGlycerides like CLA but I did not have tell her that, because the label of most fish oils supplements do not indicate the MCT/ Medium Chain TriGlyceride content. I could tell her I had switched to a brand carried by a health food store as opposed to the National Millennial Chain and had spent the same $ amount… But now I had someone who was engaging me in pursuit of the truth…
Instantly I knew she was looking for the magic bullet. MCT oils(Medium Chain TriGlycerides) are supposed to promote weight loss.
That meant the person in front of me seriously studying the label had probably seen this excerpt from Wikipedia… 3 points
Dietary relevance –references to [#] at end of this article
- Some studies have shown that MCTs can help in the process of excess calorie burning, thus weight loss.[4][5][6][7][8]
- MCTs are also seen as promoting fat oxidation and reduced food intake.[9]
- Interest in MCTs has been expressed by endurance athletes and the bodybuildingcommunity.[10]
But I knew this about MCT It started the Bullet Coffee Craze.
MCT/ Medium Chain Triglycerides were also abundant in Coconut oil which was supposedly good for melting away belly fat …
While health benefits from MCTs seem to occur, a link to improved exercise performance is weak.[9]
A number of studies back the use of MCT oil as a weight loss supplement, but these claims are not without conflict, as about an equal number found inconclusive results.[11]
I also knew how MCT works in the body and how it was absorbed thanks to surviving several anatomy and physiology classes
but instead of looking for an MCT level which means contacting the manufacturer (good luck) I asked her this:
Why aren’t you eating fresh fish ?
The woman indicated that she needed extra to achieve her goal of having a 6 pack . She indicated that she was an aerobics instructor and she needed to look the part .
I can empathize with that! Dieting or even adopting a fitness lifestyle is no guarantee to the elusive 6 pack unless your intake is on point. In addition to all the supplements you can add to the eating plan, and all the exercises you can do- the 6 pack still may not show up. But I know on thing for sure
whole foods = whole body results
I have seen 6 packs occur on chefs in training – I recall a fellow staff member at the gym who decided to eat nothing but grilled baked or broiled fish, rice, citrus fruits and water, until the 6 pack showed up. That 4 ingredient diet was harsh – but it worked because he had a secret – he sprinkled real green, slightly bitter olive oil over everything cooked. The result was chemically interesting – a very helpful mix of oils. Why?
Due to the different pathways the “stomach” GI (Gastrointestinal Tract) metabolized all the fats: both fish and plant (olive oil) therefore he lost weight. How do I know this? He only did pushups and chinups , admittedly difficult exercises, but the weight melted!(despite body fat in the double digits on a guy ) When I quizzed him, he told me that the oils in both the olive oil and the fish he ate helped suppress his cravings for carbs… and improved his cooking techniques for fish. He only ate serious fish (this was before the foodie craze) – serious fish being those that had the highest amount of pink -(muscled, active swimming fish have pink flesh). The list:
Mackerel
Wild Caught Salmon
Wild caught (pink) Tunafish in cans
Arctic Char
All the fish in this list tend to have the coveted Omega 3 fatty acids ( complex oil chains also known as the triglycerides. How does a fish get triglycerides aka Omega 3 fatty acids)
“The fish used as sources do not actually produce omega-3 fatty acids, but instead accumulate them by consuming either microalgae or prey fish that have accumulated omega-3 fatty acids”. Falk-Petersen, S.; Sargent, J. R.; Henderson, J.; Hegseth, E. N.; Hop, H.; Okolodkov, Y. B. (1998). “Lipids and fatty acids in ice algae and phytoplankton from the Marginal Ice Zone in the Barents Sea”. Polar Biology. 20 (1): 41–7. doi:10.1007/s003000050274. INIST:2356641.
Wow. I forgot that fish eat fish. I also found out that farmed fish are also fed fish oil- since they are captive, farmed fish cannot chase dinner.!!
Which explains why farmed fish have less of the triglycerides everyone wants. Even a fish has to exercise to produce the desired result. The pinker the fish , the more triglycerides, the more active the fish was- the healthier you are…
Which further underscores that a wild fish turned into a meal is better than a wild fish turned into an oil because the wild fish is chelated . Chelated means combined minerals/ vitamins /basic food building blocks. The oil, protein from the actual flesh of the fish, that glaze you broiled it in.it is all naturally combined or chelated… As food all combined as carbohydrates, proteins, fats (good Fats of all various lengths and structures) to be processed by You. That takes energy. Depending on the pathway and amount of intake , you can lose weight which is what the CLA vitamin people claim.,because CLA releases energy .
Oh yes – Coconut oil – the medium length chain triglyceride is trendy along with CLA the LOOOOONG 28 plus carbon triglyceride, which oil is better for weight loss? In all my studies of functions and chemistry I have never heard of ingestion of a fat making me less fat. I knew there were 2 kinds of fat- brown and white. I had even seen it on a cadaver dissection. But the fat was there for a reason- to protect the GI tract- that is how I knew that getting a 6 pack was going to be difficult well before I wanted one.
Food is Fuel
I propose there is weight loss in sensibly caloric amounts of a chelated fat/biologically bound fat that earned every bit of its structure when it was alive- and then it is bioavailable when digested. I am talking about flesh from…
We are just part of the food chain after all.
Food is Fuel: It is simple really once you realize there is more than one pathway the body uses to break up real materials. Fish is a real food and breaks down into materials . But a pill is material that has to be re catabolized (broken down) in order to use its materials. So a Pill is a Drug and Food Is Fuel.
What makes weight loss happen quicker?
Food – in the right amounts andrest/exercise also in the right amounts= weight loss.
Not a pill.
Why fish is better than a pill
Even the pills that do work are often biologically controlling 2-step mechanisms which makes them hard to control and are the kind of thing that requires a stint at Duke Medical. Either that or the pill illegal due to other side effects.(Ephedra) Most over the counter weight loss pills are designed to insert themselves in a pathway and control it. The more dangerous stuff just shuts the pathway down(Meth/speed/benzedrine) Food derivatives like CLA insert themselves into the pathway but a lot of customers do not get the results they want for this pill due to the complexity of fat metabolism.Like I said earlier who ever heard of ingesting a fat to get rid of fat?
That CLA is being touted as a good fat is quite complicated- I had to review some organic chemistry when I went to the research sources. CLA is a trans fat that is good for you- But Not Found In Fish. So maybe this is the one oil I would buy in pill form if I had a hard time losing weight . However buying CLA is more expensive than letting my own gut do the work of making its own CLA. “
I would rather save the money and buy fresh fish that are Wild Caught and I cook it.
https://www.seafood4unow.com
The Human body works best when things are combined in nature and then we use energy to Un Combine things and store/use it. This process is called Metabolism. You can have a slow metabolism or a fast one – you are alive because your body does all this to a fish .
Storing = Anabolism / Breaking it down and using for energy = catabolism
Understand why food is fuel
(and calories is fuel being used)
Your oil intake undergoes the anabolism/catabolism cycle too. But do not think that because it is in pill form that you have saved yourself some work. Weight loss occurs because some the oils are absorbed through the intestines and other oils are absorbed by the liver, and then you tap the energy of the oils.
If you are buying your fish oils in pill form you must be in a hurry.
But being in a hurry will give you incomplete results. Just because you can utilize CLA a long chain fat it does not mean that you have changed the caloric equation. You change the caloric equation when you body has to tackle several things at once, and store it all over a 24 hour period. It takes a day to tap what you ate yesterday. Tap it fast and the calories burned are gone when you run out of steam. Recover and you can tap it again- which is what happens in fight or flight. We all know how that works- eventually you will have to rest to be able to have enough energy to go again- this time for the long haul. They used to call this anaerobic versus aerobic but recent research shows no such division in terms of energy expenditure other than the use of glycogen over fat, which may explain why you do not look like you lost weight until you truly Go There
Want to Get There ?Here are several questions for you.
- How does the consumer know what source the fish oil is ? In other words did this fish swim in an ocean?
- Does the label gives you the ratio of fatty acid chains from saturated to unsaturated and from 3 to 6 to more complex chains up to 28+ ?
Lets answer the 2nd question: it will affect your wallet.
Does the label give you the ratio- Yes but the Oils are usually hundreds of times the Recommended Daily Allowance for well Americans as illustrated in the chart below.
You can raise your LDL to HDL ratio in the wrong direction if you do not use this extra oil as energy- the doctor can think you have high cholesterol if you constantly intake fish oil pills with as much as 300 mg of all those complex oils per day in pill form. You can also induce Hypervitaminosis A. This rarely happens in food form unless you eat seal or walrus liver, but it is a problem with people who overdo vitamins.
Vitamin fish oil pills always include DHA/ EPA * (remember that illustration Oils You Have Heard About ?) It is frustrating that the FDA does not supply the exact amount of the good oils other than to indicate that they should be 90 % of your RDA intake and the so called bad oils Saturated and short greasy chains (french fries) are not to exceed 10% . Try eating 2.4 mg of oil from your burger that you fried at home versus the one you paid $13 dollars for with 4 slices of Stilton and a beer . No wonder all my body building friends skip ground meat and do grilled fish and grilled chicken breasts., and put the $13 toward a fish.
top row= Calories in 24 hours/
middle row is amount of fish oil in grams/teaspoons
Good luck in figuring out 4.8 teaspoons of fish oil. On the other hand when you eat a fish you do not have to worry about the amount of oil, because its so mixed up with other materials that you end up with an amount that is not biologically available as fish oil- yet you are healthier. It is stored in your body.
It is not always better to have a blood profile appear like a 19th century eskimo/Inuit on paper in terms of your complex oil intake- especially when it centers on Fish oil & (see Vitamin hypervitaminosis A in Cod liver Oil)
Food Not Statins
Your Cholesterol ratio is better regulated through Food, Not Statins
It is better to eat the cod! and have a good HDL to LDL https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25057538?
The 1st Americans in the Arctic /Alaskan Hinterlands did not take pills and were healthier than most Americans until Fast Food. As you digest your next meal, take time to read the Inuit Paradox which asks
How can people who gorge on fat and rarely see a vegetable be healthier than we are? http://discovermagazine.com/2004/oct/inuit-paradox
Inuit Arctic Inhabitants have great LDL to HDL because it is their lifestyleto eat and catch fresh fish. A simpler life: Fresh air, hard work, and sleep .If you need weight loss, start by getting the fresh fish part working for you. Meatless Mondays -is working- you should try it.
Realize that Americans are doing better in their national intake of saturated fats! 1n 2017 we as a nation are only 1% away from the RDA of 10 %! Make it Fish not only on Fridays but add one more day as well… and get that fish from someone you know and trust.
The Pescetarian Advantage (Fish Lover)
Most personal trainers have their healthy sources. My friend at the gym (NYC) who became a chef introduced me to the fish mongers at the now gentrified South Street Seaport. ( See Hunts Point, Bronx now…) I currently live in the Midwest so my Ocean swimming fish comes from another trainer/chef https:/www.seafoodforunow.com.
Weekly the local (remain nameless) supermarket brings in wild salmon at 12.99 a pound but I have no idea exactly what ocean it was swimming in . I miss the informed verifiable communication from the fishermen. Instead chain stores hire personable staff who wrap the fish, but that is all. The sellers are not the buyers…In my hometown the staff at the local chain supermarket do not even eat the fish unless its fried…I am surprised that the big store chain even attempts to sell wild caught.
I live in the zip code that cares so there are 3 reliable places to get fish oil pills and there is an olive oil store but NO Fish Mongers, just supermarkets …Miss the Ocean!When you grow up here: You may or may not have access to quality fish despite the relative variety of retail as seen in this picture.
Solution: Shopping via internet
No one I know grows up being mostly a pescetarian.But if you are into health you grow into being Informed, maybe even become a foodie. Confession: I only eat porgies in New Orleans – and once in a while I will do a coldstream wild caught trout. I got educated quickly by a client who was an advocate for sustainable fish back when it was not cool… In any case i was able to do some simple fish verification / Q & A here http://www.seafoodwatch.org/
Better to eat the best ocean going fish I can find, and avoid bottom feeding fish.
By buying my fish online from seafood 4 u now I can contact the site and get answer. https://www.seafood4unow.com
picture above: Norwegian Flyfishers Club (NFC), Sør Trøndelag, Norway
Late June 2016
Target: Atlantic Salmon
Gear: Double-hand Spey rods 9-10 weight, 14’ and 15’, floating/sink tip and intermediate lines.
River conditions: Very low and clear for the time of year. 9-14 ⁰ C.
Temperature: 10-20⁰ C.
REFERENCES
4. M-P. St-Onge; P.J.H. Jones (2003). “Greater rise in fat oxidation with medium-chain triglyceride consumption relative to long-chain triglyceride is associated with lower initial body weight and greater loss of subcutaneous adipose tissue”. International Journal of Obesity. 27(12): 1565–1571. doi:10.1038/sj.ijo.0802467. PMID 12975635.
5.B. Martena; M. Pfeuffer; J. Schrezenmeir (2006). “Medium-chain triglycerides”. International Dairy Journal. 16 (11): 1374–1382. doi:10.1016/j.idairyj.2006.06.015
6.Takeuchi, H; Sekine, S; Kojima, K; Aoyama, T (2008). “The application of medium-chain fatty acids: edible oil with a suppressing effect on body fat accumulation”. Asia Pacific journal of clinical nutrition. 17 Suppl 1: 320–3. PMID 18296368.
7.St-Onge, MP; Jones, PJ (2002). “Physiological effects of medium-chain triglycerides: potential agents in the prevention of obesity”. The Journal of Nutrition. 132 (3): 329–32. PMID 11880549.
8.Papamandjaris, AA; MacDougall, DE; Jones, PJ (1998). “Medium chain fatty acid metabolism and energy expenditure: obesity treatment implications”. Life Sciences. 62 (14): 1203–15. doi:10.1016/S0024-3205(97)01143-0. PMID 9570335.
9. Clegg, M. E. (2010). “Medium-chain triglycerides are advantageous in promoting weight loss although not beneficial to exercise performance”. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition. 61 (7): 653–679. doi:10.3109/09637481003702114. PMID 20367215.
10.Talbott, Shawn M. and Kerry Hughes. (2006). The Health Professional’s Guide to Dietary Supplements. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. pp. 60–63. ISBN 978-0-7817-4672-4.
11.“Influence of the dietary intake of medium chain triglycerides on body composition, energy expenditure and satiety: a systematic review”. Nutr Hosp. 27: 103–8. 2012. doi:10.1590/S0212-16112012000100011. PMID 22566308.